Showing posts with label Problem of Silence. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Problem of Silence. Show all posts

Saturday, April 16, 2011

Against the Problem of Silence

One of the most common arguments forwarded casually by new atheists is called the "problem of silence."  It will be phrased in the form of a question, like "Why should I believe in a God who is so difficult to see?"  In essence, they are asking a rhetorical question that implies a syllogism:

P1: God is not manifestly evident to me.
P2: The Christian God, if true, wants me to know Him.
P3: A God who wants me to know Him would make Himself manifestly evident to me.
C: The Christian God is not true (does not exist).

There are several responses: